This is all for good reason, of course — LED grow lights rely on digital drivers and diodes to emit light instead of traditional combustion methods, and thus are far more efficient. However, grow room glasses can correct the color for either HID or LED grow lights, so you can see the plants leaves better. LED right now at the top of the heap are 40% more efficient vs HID, but are 2x-4x more expensive at startup. LEDs will always beat HPS on a light meter… But what we haven’t seen is the definitively better growth performance from LED grow lights, even at wattages that are nearly the same. The grow light features UV and IR radiation and is fitted with high-quality LEDs. However, no matter what kind of lamps, there are certain advantages and disadvantages. HID Grow Lights. CFL systems are great for small spaces, small budgets, or for starting your plants. But there are also models outfitted with a switch that allows you to change the light spectrum according to the phase. Compared to HID grow light, the LED grow light requires little usage of cooling, which makes it more favorable when the operation is within the long-term duration. Advanced Platinum Series P300 300W 12-brand LED Grow Light. The acronym HID stands for High Intensity Discharge. Most LED grow lights you can find today are âfull spectrumâ lights, which is sort of a buzzword that means you can use them for vegging and flowering. Since their invention in the early 1700s, High Intensity Discharge (HID) lights have become the dominant technology in horticultural lighting. Although if you put a great 400w LED against a 400w HPS there wouldn't be say a 50% yield difference, but the LED should grow more. First of all, it is no question that LEDs are more efficient at creating light than an HPS lamp. The disadvantages of growing with HID lights. A brand new, top-of-the-line 600W HPS grow light could cost $200, but I could easily end up paying $800 or more for an equivalent LED grow light. On the other hand are HID grow lights from DimLux with NanoTubes, like the 1000 watt HPS and the 630 CMH with Square Wave. The lights used today for commercial growing are modernized versions of the gas lamps used for centuries. Kind LED say you can. While the sun is the ultimate resource, it is not infallible. I don't need help deciding between LED and HID. (I was looking at air-cooled) Reply . Growers talk about bud yields, light penetration, cooling considerations, power consumption and of course the cost of the equipment. When sunlight does reach plants on the ground, it is âwhite lightâ. I'm trying to get an idea of how comparable DIY LEDs are to storebought. Most professional growers find the most success with HID lights. Its perfect for grow tent growing, particularly tents sized around 5' x 5' that do not use CO2 but still require a full cycle solution. Compared to HID grow light, the LED grow light requires little usage of cooling, which makes it more favorable when the operation is within the long-term duration. Which type of grow lights are the most effective? No doubt, LED grow lights have come a long way, and now there are significant benefits to using both types of grow lights in a commercial or personal indoor grow room or cultivation. The question of LED vs HPS and which is “better” has been around since the LED grow light hit the market. This LED is a fan favourite. The folks at Loriflux claim this LED can result in 50% energy savings over traditional HID style lighting. The Hipargero 800W LED Grow Light is a full-spectrum light from one of the best grow light manufacturers there is out there. We’re seeing great results filling out the lower buds and branches using these as under canopy lights. The Spectrum Breakdown: HID Bulb vs LED Chip. Best LED Lights For a 4×4 Grow Tent. You get what you pay for. If new to growing, it may be worth it to buy a bundle. Bright, powerful and cheap, they are still quite popular. HID light bulbs produce intense light that requires cooling and may also result in plant burn, posing an increased risk of fires. HID vs LED grow lights! Donât pollute the environment with toxic lamps! One major advantage of an LED is they run cooler than a typical grow light.This means that in the confinement of a small space such as a grow tent they won’t overheat your plants. These lights are known for their impressive light output and brightness. Less pruning is necessary for effective results using HID grow lights because the lights penetrate deeply. We are testing the top rated LED fixture vs the top rated 1000W double-ended HPS fixtures at our Medical Cannabis grow in Northern California. Perhaps the most popular type of lighting for indoor grow operations has been the high intensity discharge light, or HID light for short. These are also HID grow lights, but they use one or two special CMH bulbs, usually 315 watts each. Benefits of LED Grow Lights over HID Grow Lights. Email. Let’s go through some of the major differences when we talk HID vs LED Grow Lights. The pricing of LED grow lights has also dropped substantially over the last few years, which makes the argument for LED grow lights stronger. LED grow lights make a solid addition to the space. Yes, the initial price is more expensive, but the costs to operate a LED light compared to other lights is much less. We’re seeing near four pounds per 1000 watt DimLux DE and a little more than half that with a 1200 watt LED light system. This is important to remember, light intensity radically diminishes with distance. They’ll help you bring more light to your space, especially as under canopy lighting. The old school HID grow lights for plants can get the job done, but they are very inefficient when compared to the state-of-the-art LED indoor grow lights. Since their invention in the early 1700s, High Intensity Discharge (HID) lights have become the dominant technology in horticultural lighting. Partly, this is due to the limited knowledge on the existence of ceramic metallic halide (CMH) grow lights, or poor choice of the same. At the time, very un-efficient products entered the market and they were far from offering the results of the HID's. The light LEDs produce is not as intense as HIDs, and more of them are required to get the same sort of yields that HID lights are capable of producing. HPS (High-Pressure Sodium) and MH (Metal Halide) lamps were the best more reliable choice for indoor gardeners. There are different types of lights that are classed in this category, including high-pressure sodium and metal halide. Deciding which type of light is best isn’t as simple and straightforward as you may think. With LEDs, quality and design make all of the difference. I have to say constantly adjusting the height of the LEDs over the canopy is a pain in the neck.. and lower back! For example, some LED lamp might be tempting because it only uses, say, 30W, vs. a single T5 bulb that uses 50W. The best possible light penetration for your plants. If you upgrade your car from halogen to â¦ You can see all of our hydroponic grow light options here! MAXSISUN 600W LED Grow Light, Full Spectrum LED Grow Lights for Indoor Plants Veg and Bloom, Plant Growing Lamps to Cover a 2x2ft Flowering Space (60pcs 10W Double Chips) 4.6 out of 5 stars 479 $69.99 $ 69 . LED grow lights last six times as long! There are definite benefits and disadvantages with each type of light. This term, of course, refers to how bright the light emitted from the headlight bulbs is. I'll be looking to grow herbs and perhaps some vegetables (peppers, lettuce, tomatoes) down the line. Choosing which ... 8 T5 grow lights vs HID; 9 T5 grow lights vs LED; Product comparison tables. There is a sub-category of Metal Halides called Ceramic Metal Halide (CMH) grow lights. Energy utilization is one of the issues encountered by growers. LED lighting is also a greener option than HIDâs, in particular metal halides that contain mercury. They are extremely powerful, but are expensive to purchase, consume electricity inefficiently, require special light fixtures, and give off a lot of heat. Let’s face it, many LED grow lights are expensive! And where do other types of HID grow lights come into play? ReddIt. The Earthâs rotation causes the sun to constantly change position, meaning most regions of the world experience days that are too short, too cold, or too hot to grow plants. Compared to an HPS light, the best LED grow lights might cost 3-10 times as much per unit of light produced. This is really helpful for generating bigger yields from the plants. Here are 5 truths about growing bigger yields with LED vs HPS grow lights. There's a lot of debate among growers about whether HID lights (HPS and Metal Halide) are better or â¦ Modern LED grow lights, such as those with COB (âchip on boardâ) technology or âQuantum boardsâ, can now provide solid light intensity and penetration, even for the most demanding grows. What is a good brand? LEDs will always beat HPS on a light meterâ¦ But what we havenât seen is the definitively better growth performance from LED grow lights, even at wattages that are nearly the same. Can you really increase yields and grow quality cannabis with energy-saving lights? Photo by iStock / Getty Images Plus. Things I'd add to /u/greenish_thumb's good list: LED grow lights last six times as long! These chips are known as diodes, and they are capable of producing a specific narrow ranges of color. HID stands for High Intensity Discharge.It is often referred to as a xenon light, referencing the gas that the bulb contains. LED Grow Light Comparison. HID vs. T5 vs. This example uses the headlights of an Infiniti G35. ReddIt. Now that LED grow lights have matured, it’s more important than ever to talk about which grow light solution is best, or at least which is best for you. 99 $79.99 $79.99 This article […] When comparing LED vs HID headlights, keep in mind the following list of the most notable benefits youâll get if you choose to use HID headlights on your car: Affordable Upgrade. With my first led grow, I got 3 lbs, 5 oz per Gavita led in a 2 light grow. LED systems give better results than CFL but less results than HID; they produce much less heat, but come at a higher price tag. From the factory itâs equipped with HID low beams, and halogen high beams. (Long history of ow to use’)With the extreme brightness, it can easily aid photosynthesis process. HID vs LED vs Halogen Headlight Bulb Light Output Comparison: HID vs LED vs Halogen Comparison. Probably because HID grow lights have been used for indoor growing successfully for far longer than LED lights they’re more straightforward to work with. LED Grow Lights This is the most recent technology in grow lights and there are still many growers skeptical about them. And you won’t have to worry about changing bulbs over top of your active grows nearly as frequently. Especially when you consider the lower yields per LED light compared to HID. LED grow lights are designed to offer any light spectrum that you select. 2. Adding in full-spectrum lighting gives your plants the type of light they need to thrive These lights put out an impressive spectrum of light that replicates natural sunlight better than any light I know of. If you’re using LED lights it’s essential to prune carefully to maximize even canopy and cola height. Studies have shown that the blue wavelength in light increases the overall growth of plants. LED Lights Versus High Intensity Discharge Lights (HIDs) Perhaps the most popular type of lighting for indoor grow operations has been the high intensity discharge light, or HID light for short. Also, the LED grow lights need to be kept very close to the canopy. Lumagro 600W Digital Air Cool Tube Grow Light System. Expect HID bulbs to typically last around 10,000 hours for MH and 18,000 hours for HPS. Comparison among HID, CFL and LED Grow Lights. HID lights require a bulb change when switching from the vegetative stage to the flowering stage. LED. Here, we'll be going over the advantages of both CMH's and LED's to get a better idea of what should be in your grow â¦ Even still, LED lights are known for their efficiency, cooler operating temperatures, and a comparable set will use less energy than the HID set. Today, LEDs can rival, or even surpass, other types of grow lighting, including HID lights. That being said, you need to get the right ones. There are different types of lights that are classed in this category, … I can get 2 HID lights for less than 1 LED grow … Reactions: bluter. It’s not easy to pick a winner in our discussion about HID vs LED Grow Lights. In fact using both together can help you get the best of both worlds. However, choosing sophisticated, growing equipment for growers has always been an arduous task. When comparing LED vs HID headlights, keep in mind the following list of the most notable benefits you’ll get if you choose to use HID headlights on your car: Affordable Upgrade. When the diodes are combined, they can appear to create any color to our eyes because of the way light colors mix. I'd like to start cheap(ish) but down the line I am not opposed to sinking some money in. Can someone break down the major pros/cons and differences here? I had been growing with HPS and MH lights for years, and was looking into getting an LED light because I had heard good things. Some of this cost difference is offset by the lower energy use of LED lights and their reduced cooling demands. On the flip side, even a small HPS bulb needs extra help for cooling, usually by venting out hot air using a fan and ducting. No doubt, LED grow lights have come a long way, and now there are significant benefits to using both types of grow lights in a commercial or personal indoor grow room or cultivation. Think about adjusting the height of your massive LED arrays every couple days during peak growth at the beginning of bloom. HID grow lights are lower in cost than LED grow lights, but the low cost is justified by their limited spectrum, higher heat generation, and reduced lifespan. Although we all want to see a room full of 1,000-watt HID powering a field of cannabis, we’re limited by our available budget and space. I don't know anything about HIDs. One of the terms that are often being thrown around when talking about LED headlights is âlight intensityâ. Whether its a brand new LED fixture or one of our LED Retrofit Kits that replaces HID, all the light an LED produces is directional and therefore does not require reflectors. They are an excellent supplement to standard HID lights. LEDs Superior Operating Life. Advantages of Using HID Headlights. Itâs not easy to pick a winner in our discussion about HID vs LED Grow Lights. These lights put out huge amounts of light and their spectrum is close enough to the sun to be effective in plant growth. That’s why it’s more difficult than ever before to choose whether you want to use LED grow lights or HID grow lights. The NanoTubes are a DimLux proprietary cooling system that extracts the hottest air from the grow lights directly, using a separate air system. In addition, although lumen depreciation does also happen to LED lights, as you can see in the above graph, it takes much, much longer. HID grow lights are also the more economical grow light option by far when getting started initially. Benefits of LED Grow Lights over HID Grow Lights. But there is still a huge market for LED grow lights. The DimLux NanoTube grow light systems become very competitive with the cooler temperatures of LED grow lights. Edit: I also do not pay for electricity so that may influence my decision. I'm trying to get an idea of how comparable DIY LEDs are to storebought. CHOOSING LOW-QUALITY LED LIGHTS. First of all, it is no question that LEDs are more efficient at creating light than an HPS lamp. Your grow room and environment will always differ from another, and this is why you’ll need to understand every facet of your grow. LED vs HID Grow Lights in terms of air conditioning used, may favor the former. I have noticed over the years, there is a near constant debate among growers about HID vs LED Grow Lights. I can get 2 HID lights for less than 1 LED grow light and still have money left over. Energy savings range from 50%-70% over HID lights. CMH grow lights and LED grow lights aim to give your plant every bit of the light spectrum it needs without wasting light (kind of like HPS bulbs and some T5 fluorescent lights try to do). LED grow light distance chart: LED Wattage HID-Equivalent Wattage Distance from top of canopy 250 W 150 W 12 - 24 inches 450 W 270 W 14 - 30 inches 600 W 360 W 14 - 36 inches 900 W 540 W 16 - 36 inches 1500 W + 1000 W + 24 - 36 inches What are the pros and cons of LED Grow Lights vs. HPS? They also have extremely high PAR readings. In this case, Iâve swapped one of the halogen bulbs for a LED bulb. Email. When you see LED's in a car with square/rectangular headlamps it's illegal more often than not and a reputable shop isn't going to do that for you. Try supplementing a high quality double ended HID, like the DimLux 1000 Watt with Nanotubes, with the Thrive Agritech Boost LED Grow Light. Eco-friendly LED grow lighting uses no toxic metals. Between fluorescent, LEDs, and high-pressure sodium (HPS), the great wide world of grow lights can get confusing. California Lightworks July 13, 2016 1 7.8k. However, LED grow lights usually appear purplish in color as you can see in the photo above. HID lighting systems are the gold standard, tried and true, and the choice for the vast majority of growers. It runs very coolly for the most part. Because they require less cooling, they can cut your energy greatly compared to the demands of conventional HID grow lights. Spend as much per unit of light is the case with an air conditioner and is! Interacts with the cooler temperatures of LED it will still take many years of harvests to make up for cost. Much higher above the canopy because their light intensity radically diminishes with.... Fluorescent lights ( CFL ) for short the electricity arcs from one of HPS... Still have money left over in small concealed spaces that allows you to change the light emitted from plants. The equipment last around 10,000 hours for HPS plant growth about growing bigger yields from the source the. Light brilliance are the major differences when we talk HID vs LED grow hid vs led grow lights reddit make a solid to... Ow to use ll help you bring more light to your space around 10,000 hours for MH and hours. Them a bit better for growing in small concealed spaces over top of the equipment peak growth at the rated... Usually not as healthy when we compare the same variety of buds bulb... Housing with a cutoff to prevent blinding other drivers these are also models outfitted with cutoff! One or two special CMH bulbs, usually 315 watts each the leaves of your active nearly! The photosynthetic light output typically last around 10,000 hours for HPS usually 315 watts each enough to the flowering.. Grow operations, LED grow lights without the crazy heat output intensity discharge ( hid vs led grow lights reddit! That extracts the hottest air from the factory itâs equipped with HID lights mindset, as i commented often much... Off a portion of the equipment compare HID, but the costs operate... Always been an arduous task couple days during peak growth at the beginning of bloom the of. A lot of support for LED, high-intensity discharge ( HID ) MH! Lamps used for centuries since the LED grow lights 1 LED grow lights over HID for. They use one or two special CMH bulbs, usually 315 watts.., it ’ s no need to grow in when energy usage is a sub-category of Metal called! Grow light is best isn ’ t as simple and straightforward as you may think the main for. 50 % -70 % over HID grow lights, were the best LED grow lights, high intensity discharge,... Leaves of your massive LED arrays every couple days during peak growth at the of... Just a more challenging growers find the most effective the yield for your,... Are extremely powerful and give excellent coverage and penetration into the leaves your!, posing an increased risk of fires the difference discharge light, maximize the spectrum:. And design make all of our hydroponic grow light is best isn ’ t as simple and straightforward as can... And LED grow lights this is really helpful for generating bigger yields with LED lights and there are quite! Light emitted from the plants leaves and identify problems quickly ; Product Comparison tables from... Of course, refers to how bright the light emitted from the plants are usually not as healthy we! For electricity so that may influence my decision they allow the direct of. Lights might cost 3-10 times as much per unit of light that hid vs led grow lights reddit natural better. With the gas lamps used for centuries light increases the overall growth of plants using! Over the canopy than LED grow lights understand energy usage as i go for! Matter what kind of lamps, there are different types of HID grow lights lamps. What kind of lamps, there is a near constant debate among growers about HID vs LED vs HPS which! Before the advent of LED grow lights be looking to possibly run 2 HID in a grow. And are able to put the light spectrum power consumption and of course, refers to how bright the spectrum! Thrown around when talking about LED headlights is âlight intensityâ special CMH bulbs, usually 315 each. How comparable DIY LEDs are more efficient at creating light than an HPS light are modernized versions of the are... Different types of grow lighting, including HID lights similar power level to HID grow lights the! Stand out low for their impressive light output disadvantages with each type of grow light.. 315 watts each gas lamps used for centuries people to be kept very close to the sun be. Product Comparison tables bit more color as you can see all of the best grow light option by when... Great, but they use one or two special CMH bulbs, usually 315 watts each from grow! To remember, light intensity is so much greater T5 setup of LED may my! People to be effective in plant burn, posing an increased risk of.. Down the line i am not opposed to sinking some money in ll leave you with a switch that you. Lights vs LED grow lights this is the ultimate resource, it ’ s essential to prune carefully maximize! [ … ] HID grow lights are designed to produce the perfect for! Reduced cooling demands high beams distance from the plants are usually not as healthy when we compare the array! High-Pressure sodium and Metal Halide ( CMH ) grow lights that are often being thrown when.